I love weird west. I actually wrote a Weird West intro adventure for OSE that’s free now. Invasion of the Tuber Dudes
That’s a fantastic idea. I, for one, really like that.
3 Likes
Colliding two questions into one, I think an interesting title would be “Defence as Leather” (the sequels being Chain and Plate, ofc). Or something of that sort, letting people know the kind of thing it would be focused on (usability, system neutrality). Also is the google doc being used or not, I couldn’t quite tell
3 Likes
I love that name. Definitely my favorite so far.
We’re not using the google doc anymore. Sorry. I’ve taken the link out of that thread to make it less confusing.
3 Likes
I like the idea of thematically-linked content, but also like seeing whatever eclectic ideas the community can throw together. Are they mutually exclusive?
It puts me in mind of the time when Games Workshop’s White Dwarf used to be a reversible magazine - you could read it one way and see all the Warhammer and 40k articles, or flip it round to have a Lord of the Rings cover and content. It meant that the articles on the other subject were always upside down, but I liked the distinction it gave the different settings in the physical magazine. I appreciate that wouldn’t come across so well in an online zine, but if it were ever available in print…
3 Likes
I can’t find the right post, but at some point @Kingroy23 mentioned the idea of having an End of the Year Codex with the best content from the community. We could do both: a thematically-linked content for regular numbers and a less frequent edition with the best content we could make.
3 Likes
Content
I’d like us to focus on a big thing and fill that thing with tons of detail and inspiration.
But what is that thing?
-A small-ish adventure location
-??
Stuff to round it out:
-Adventure hooks/rumours (ways to add this to your campaign)
-Bestiary
-Encounter tables
-Cool New Spells
-Cool New Items
-PLAYER HANDOUTS!
-??
Name
I think “The Pit” is pretty cool. “The Pit: An OSR Zine From the Depths of the Earth” or something like that as the subtitle would help it stand out.
System
Generic OSR gets my vote. Attacks as a two-handed sword, defense as chainmail. Maybe use the B/X Gold Piece standard for currency.
Setting
Fantasy, sword & planet, weird fantasy, horror fantasy, that sort of thing.
-I’m down with a Norse setting
-I also like a DarkSoulsian grimscape
-I like the worldbuilding ideas in this thread https://discourse.osrrpg.com/t/convergent-storytelling-in-osr-games/269 only applied in a smaller scale.
-Sword & Planet He-Man silliness?
-Cheap 70s barbarian fantasy? (oh yeah, that’s just DnD)
Themes
-Rebuilding, sure.
-Community-building? Helping a torn community get back on its feet. This would be an alternative to wealth-accumulation driven gameplay. Or a parallel system where PCs make choices between helping the community or getting paid well. Paid by whom? The interdimensional mining company that operates around The Pit?
-Colonialism or capitalism (as the modern force causing some of the same problems as colonialism)
Brainstorming ideas
Yeah, what about a big fantasy mining corp that’s delving into The Pit, robbing its riches while the native population/workers get used? So the PCs could fill a role either helping the big corp or helping the people. (I do recognise the White Saviour theme emerging here, but we could work on that…)
Maybe The Pit is mining something weird, like the brains of an elder god, triggering psychic visions, or it’s a big pit of living meat, being mined for food. Sorry, got stuck on the mining aspect, but that’s what a lot of pits result from, right?
p.s.
How about we make a random table with a bunch of community produced ideas/phrases (multiple columns), and have people roll some prompts from that? Just as a brainstorming method…
4 Likes
I think it would be a bit of a missed opportunity if the theme of the first issue wasn’t quarantine, plague, etc…
1 Like
My thinking is quite close to yours, especially a structure of…
I think we have enough to get started but I’m thinking of waiting another day or two to give everyone another day or two to either express interest or suggest a direction to move in.
3 Likes
I’d totally be down for Weird West (Westerns are my favorite genre by far when it comes to movies/tv).
Agreed.
I like this title the best, and maybe we could add some sort of subtitle to mention the Pit and the content that lies within.
Agreed with everything in your post. I especially like the idea of community building, that could be really cool.
I love this idea.
3 Likes
@Grognard @maderschramm What do you think of this idea? This end-of-year zine would be more about everyone writing whatever their forte happens to be.
2 Likes
I think it’s conciliatory and not what I’d want for the standard, regularly released zine.
It makes more sense to me to reverse it and have a once a year zine on a single topic while a normal release showcases all of what’s happening in the OSR, not just one generic fantasy setting.
2 Likes
Again, I very much agree with maderschramm.
The great thing about RPGs in general, and OSR and Fanzines in particular is that they are more often than not and by their very nature, eclectic. They cover a wide range of topics and opinions, particularly if there are more than a few contributors. I think if you let people write about what they are passionate about (anything!) it will provide the most value to the readers and you will get the best content possible. Of course there has to be an editor, you need not accept or publish anything that anyone sends. But if you limit the scope (too much), I think quality, amount of contributions and passion will suffer.
Once you have say 3+ Zines with very wide-ranging topics about the OSR, you could still choose to collate some of the articles into a thematic end of year or end of season special zine, you could even request a few more articles to round out these specials.
An example, I would be excited to write about something extremely practical and niche, but still of quite a bit of importance to most (beginning) RPGers, it is something I have spend a lot of time thinking about, on and off, for decades now hehe.
The topic is:
What are the actual practical (and best) stuff you need (and bunch of things you might simply want) to begin playing?
I would subdivide that into tiers.
A “I want to spend $10 and still have a full game system, dice and everything else I need to play, forever!” B. I want to spend up to $ 50
C. $200 and up.
D. I want Iced out Dice/and the sky is the limit on what it costs!
I have to ask, in what Zine theme would this weird topic even fit? XD It would probably never come up.
Another example: I have 0 interest in the Weird West. But I would not mind in the least if one issue of the Zine featured some content relating to that! Who knows, I might enjoy the 1 or 2 articles! But if most or the entire Zine was made up of content related to that, well, i’d have nothing to contribute and likely would only scan it a bit, not read it.
Perhaps I liken my ideal Zine format/content to my favourite Punk Zines of old, they would always have band and gig and record reviews and pictures,… (= the equivalent of OSR staples, like adventures, handouts, new items and spells), but they would also always feature 2 to 6 columns or sections that were more like editorials and the topics discussed in those would range from the esoteric, to the personal to anything! interesting tangentially or totally related to Punk (OSR). And tbh, that combination is exactly what always kept the Zine predictable enough yet also fresh and providing the maximum value to the reader and also meant the widest range of readers were interested in it. It is no co-incidence that the really big Zines that printed tens of thousands of copies every month all followed this idea (Maximum Rock n Roll, Slug and Lettuce etc).
Anyway, at the end of the day, whoever does the most work gets to decide as far as I am concerned, not my call. I will just be happy if the Zine comes into existence in not too super long, in whatever form it takes. 
5 Likes
I’d love to hop on with some writing/tables and very badly drawn art.
I think maderschramm and Grognard have the right idea. Run a Special Encounter edition every so often with a theme or collate past stuff into a best of…
I know I shift between science-fantasy and stone age and post-apoc with alarming regularity.
3 Likes
So we run into the inevitable conflict of many chefs in the kitchen. At least 3 people want an eclectic zine and at I think around the same want a featured location.
I think you all make a good case for the “kitchen sink” approach. I’ll just a few things why it doesn’t excite me, in table form naturally.
Roll 1d6
1. With an eclectic zine, each of us will be working on something different, so it would be less collaborative.
2. If we have a lot of different systems, it will be hard for the editors to check everything. Whereas I’m guessing everyone here has system mastery of generic OSR.
3. The end product has less utility: a scattershot approach will by definition miss as many people as it hits. Generic OSR as opposed to mothership & mork borg + ose +runequest+etc is more useable by more people.
4. I don’t think it’s true that having a collective goal (a pit, say) will in any way eliminate the different ideas and personalities that reside on this board. It will in fact unite them in a way that totally separate entries might not.
5. I’d argue that the best this board has to offer is more than the sum of it’s parts, otherwise it’s essentially a pdf of assorted blog posts.
6. We’re going to give this away for free, but still from a marketing standpoint: this is a zine about (all the strange encounters in a pit, or whatever we go with) is perhaps easier to “sell” than “this is a zine where anything goes”
I don’t hate the smorgasbord zine idea at all. There is something cool about into leaning into a gonzo, anything goes approach. I think, however, that both the writing process (being able to connect our work together) and the end result (a uniform collection of ideas) will be improved by a central location. Just my 2 cents.
So it seems we’re at a little bit of an impasse. Nobody wants to force their vision onto everyone else, so the question is: how to proceed? Open it up to a vote? Roll a die? Make two different zines?
Let’s figure it out, one way or another, and get going on this thang!
2 Likes
This is exactly why a varied zine is the best option. Every single one of those cooks can prepare a dish that then makes it into the finished product, which is then edited and cleaned up to make a cohesive zine. Think of something like Dungeon or Dragon magainze - the contributors wrote articles that enhanced the product as a whole, but weren’t tied to a specific setting or genre. You could see everything from short fiction to modules to tables to miniature painting.
With the other authors, maybe. With the editors it would be more so because of the point brought up in #2:
Hence the need for collaboration of the editors and the contributors.
While not everyone will gain as much out of every article included, more people will still read the zine, even for that one article they might find interesting. This boosts readership and increases the reach of The Pit, which hopefully boosts our attendance here as well.
Rather than being “just another Generic OSR Zine”, the Pit’s zine would truly be a smattering of the best and brightest contributors of all realms of the OSR gathered in one place. You might not play Mothership but reading that article might get you interested in the system, or at least get you on this forum to talk about it.
I disagree, everything will be whitewashed into one thing by the editors. It’s just a collab piece at that point. Look at Death Frost Doom (example because it’s sitting next to me as I’m writing this) - pick out what Raggi wrote and what Zak wrote - you can’t.
The editing is what pulls it together at that point. Look again at Dungeon or Dragon magazine. It’s still greater than the sum of its parts even though its parts are distinct.
The pitch is easy. To reiterate what I said above, The Pit isn’t “just another Generic OSR Zine”, it’s a smattering of the best and brightest contributors from all realms of the OSR gathered in one place. With something for everyone, the zine can bring ideas to your table or introduce you to something you’ve never heard of before.
I think we’ve both said our pieces. You’re quarterbacking this thing, so you’ll need to make a decision. Do we want a collab piece or do we want something unique that only this board could create? You know where my vote lies.
4 Likes
I think this is where we need to look. We could gather up what made both of those great (and successful), compose a list of those aspects, and start pulling them directly to get people working on them.
We don’t have to restrict ourselves in anyway. We should promote OSR goodies from just about any setting or system, as if we are TSR promoting our products with the goal of getting people to jump in. That also doesn’t mean we have to restrict ourselves in dedicating a portion of the zine to a continual setting, or generic theme, that allows for people looking for creative restrictions or guidelines to fire up their drive to create content for the zine. Half the zine is dedicated to anything promoting OSR curated or created by the Pit, half the zine dedicated to a new look into our continual, exclusive setting/theme/world/concept composed of content created by us.
An OSR zine, “featuring” our setting/theme. I think that would be my vote.
5 Likes
Easy solution, best of all worlds. I concur.
4 Likes
I suggested it but this is a community project and any one person making unilateral decisions probably isn’t healthy.
This seems the best way. We can have a cohesive setting/adventure as the main dish but also have a bunch of entrees to go along with it. That way people can contribute in whatever fashion they desire. Good thinking!
4 Likes
You’ve convinced me 
I’m definitely coming around to the idea of a more varied zine, and the more I think about it the more I like the idea.
2 Likes
The best way to run something like this is to have a benevolent dictator that can be ousted at any point by anyone. No decision is worse than a bad decision, because even if a decision is bad, it’s possible to fix it.
What if everyone got a set amount of page space, to do whatever they want with? If people want to collab, they can pool their pages towards a particular topic?
Another $0.02, I love the idea of a big “feature article” with a bunch of other random things. Like a full multi-page dungeon for half of the zine, with a bunch of one-pagers for literally anything else people want.
I also think system-free main content, with system reviews, and hell maybe having a couple chunks of Joesky tax after each review for that particular system?
3 Likes